Remarks to UO Senate - November 18, 2026

Good afternoon colleagues, 

Thank you, President Davis and Senator Pandoh for your updates. We meet today in the midst of the public feedback phase of the Academic Modification Advisory Committee or AMAC process.  

In the three weeks since we released our preliminary budget proposal, hundreds of comments have been submitted through the AMAC feedback form. The committee has also held two public online listening sessions; two more will take place later this week. As you will hear from President Davis later in the meeting, the deans have been actively consulting with units and leadership in their colleges—and even if it hasn’t always been smooth, the feedback is being heard and it is shaping decisions. 

This week alone, Karl and I have engaged with the Officers of Administration through the OA Council, United Academics, the Faculty Advisory Council, Senate Leadership, and AMAC, as we continue to review the feedback we are receiving every day through this process.  

Throughout this period of consultation, I have returned to a passage I read earlier this summer in Robert Goheen’s book, The Human Nature of a University. Goheen was the long-time president of Princeton (1957-1972) who oversaw the introduction of women into the university in … 1969(!)—for the record, that’s 93 years after the University of Oregon welcomed its first coeducational class when it first opened its doors to students on October 16,1876. (And I can’t let this remark pass without mentioning that the University of Oregon graduated its first women in our first graduating class in 1878—Nellie Condon, daughter of Thomas Condon, graduated in a class of five, four of whom were men. Nellie was the valedictorian.) But I digress…

Robert Goheen not only oversaw the introduction of women into Princeton, he was also a strong advocate for broad consultation in academic decision-making. This is the passage to which I have been returning throughout our process:

For when decisions are discussed widely and hammered out jointly among the principal parties of interest, they tend to be sounder institutional decisions, and the additional time and effort required to achieve them that way is usually justified by the wider, readier acceptance they are likely to find (The Human Nature of a University, p. 7-8). 

Whether the difficult decisions we will have to make in December are widely and readily accepted remains to be seen, but I am convinced that they will have been made sounder by the time we have taken to discuss them broadly and to work through them together.  

We are listening, considering, and reflecting on the input that we are receiving, and there will be adjustments to our proposal based on this feedback. In fact, by the time we posted the preliminary plan on October 28th, we already knew our thinking had evolved in certain areas. But we committed to a clear schedule with AMAC over the summer months, and posting our preliminary plans at the end of October was an important part of that process. Still, part of what makes this period of feedback and deliberation so difficult is that it remains so dynamic. Approaches have been shifting as new suggestions are made, new ideas considered. As we have said from the beginning, no decisions will be made until December.  

Out of respect for the people and academic programs involved, we are intent on responding to the community's input according to the process and timeline that has been established. For now, that means living with uncertainty a little longer. I recognize that this is most difficult for those whose programs are under review. 

But I am confident that — as it was with our preliminary budget proposal developed in partnership with AMAC — the final decisions we make will ultimately be better because of this extensive feedback process. We also recognize that once decisions are made, there will need to be continued discussion and collaboration over the months to come about how we implement them, particularly as they relate to structural changes and possible mergers. Those conversations will continue past December and into the new year.  

As we move from planning to implementation, my hope is that the lessons we are learning and the relationships we are building now will enable us to navigate and realize these changes together.  

**** 

While I know there is a lot of focus at present on the details of our plan, I want to use this opportunity with you today to step back. 

Our preliminary budget plan contains many hard and painful proposals, but it does not lay off any tenure-track faculty. It also does not close any undergraduate academic programs.  

We have found ways on the enterprise level to re-direct millions of dollars so that we can alleviate pressure on our Education and General Fund budgets. We can only draw on these funds so far without putting the institution’s future at risk, but this direction speaks to our desire to keep education and research at the center of every budget decision we make. 

Our proposal is also rooted in a vision for our future that we have been developing for months. This vision seeks to refine our research focus, concentrating our investments in research areas where we can achieve national distinction and where our strengths, geography, and history provide us with unique advantages. 

Additionally, our vision document asks us to find ways make the University of Oregon a destination for undergraduate students: giving prospective students clear and compelling reasons to choose us in this more competitive recruiting environment, including more faculty-led instruction and research opportunities. 

Many of the comments we have received on our budget proposal thus far are from faculty and graduate students focused on protecting programs about which they care deeply. I respect the strength of the advocacy we are hearing. I understand the deep connection people have to the programs they cherish. As someone who has spent a career trying to nurture and preserve humanities PhD programs, I understand the feeling of being in perpetual “crisis,” and I know how difficult it is to remain creative and adaptive in times of intense transformation and change.  

The vision document invites us to consider the areas of research where we are best positioned to lead, even as we enhance the rich liberal arts educational experience we provide to undergraduates. It requires us to take a proactive approach to graduate education reform at a time when the placement market for PhDs is contracting.  

We envision a shift in which a sharper strategic focus on specific areas of research will allow us to invest in signature PhD programs centered on the educational and professional success of our graduate students. The teaching capacity we will lose in this transition will need to be filled by hiring career track faculty to support the broad liberal arts education we are committed to delivering. If we do this well, we will be at the forefront of a transition in graduate education in the United States. I have been in numerous conversations at the national level over the course of the last few years that recognize the degree to which the traditional model for doctoral education is unsustainable, but very few have a strategic vision about how to reform our approach in a way that makes good on our commitment to graduate and undergraduate education and research alike.  

The strategy outlined by the vision document recognizes that our doctoral cohorts will be smaller overall. In return, we can invest more deeply in the doctoral programs that align with our priorities and purpose as a public research university. I recognize that we are aspiring to do something very difficult during a challenging period of disruptive change.  

The educator and writer Parker Palmer describes what he calls "the tragic gap," the space "between the way things are and the way we know they might be." He doesn’t expect that gap to close. Instead, he invites us to learn to stand in it, "faithfully holding the tension between reality and possibility." (A Hidden Wholeness: The Journey Toward an Undivided Life, pg. 170)

That seems to me a fair description of where we are right now. It may be an uncomfortable place to linger, but it is also a generative place to be.  And I’m grateful to be standing in it with colleagues who care so deeply about this university, even if you disagree with parts or all of our plan.  

Your input makes our decisions better, and I am grateful for the time and attention you have dedicated to this important process.  

Thank you.